The question investors should be asking right now


Hi Reader,

In a recent article titled Rethinking Risk, Jack Raines had this to say about today's investing environment:

"It was far, far riskier investing a year and a half ago than it is today. Interest rates are returning to their historical range, the S&P's earnings are back at a healthy level, excess liquidity is leaving the system, and you can no longer make easy money playing hot potato with a worthless asset.
 
Risk happens in the past, and we act on it in the present. We think, 'All of these bad things happened over the last 12 months, now is a horrible time to be in the market.' While we should think, 'A lot of the bad stuff is out of the way, now is a great time to invest more money in the market.'"

When prices fall, it often feels like risk is rising.

The irony is that it's the opposite that's true. Generally speaking, risk falls as prices fall.

To this point, Raines said,

"Risk is a paradox. It is highest when we forget it exists, and it is lowest when it's all we can think about."

And right now, it's clear that risk is the main thing on people's minds.  

This being the case, wary investors seem eager to lock in fixed returns at a time when future returns for global stocks are more attractive than they have been in years.

I think it's wise to question whether the decision to sell now (to lock in fixed returns) is likely to be prudent or foolish given a little time. 

There's plenty of historical data to support the stay-the-course mentality.

For example, since 1950, the average 5-year cumulative return for U.S. stocks following a decline of 25% from all-time highs is ... +83.3%! (Source: Ben Carlson)

And that's just the average. Which means some returns were much higher.

But because I'm sure you're curious...

...the worst 5-year return was +21.5%!

Comparatively, the current 5-year Treasury rate is 4.35%.

Over 5 years, that's a cumulative return of +21.8%, which is on par with the worst historical experience for stocks.

With inflation still high, the question we should be asking ourselves is:

Which is riskier rom a real-return perspective over the next 5 years:
The asset with a likely return of +21.8%?
Or the one with an average return of +83.3%?

As fearful souls panic and stuff their money under the mattress, I expect many of them to experience seller's remorse once they have the benefit of hindsight.

Staying the Course

I remain emphatic about staying the course because every bear market in history has been followed by a strong bull market.

Why would this one be any different?

That said, I understand it's uncomfortable because, during a market downturn, it always feels like the higher probability is that things will get worse.

And that may be what happens.

But we aren't investing for days or months...

...we're investing for decades. (Yes, even those who are in retirement!)

Keeping this perspective in the forefront of your mind is the key to a successful investing experience.

New Subscriber?

📖 Read last weeks newsletter: The Fed's Bizarro World + Free Year-end Planning Resources​

As always, reply to this email with any comments or questions. I read and respond to every message :)

Stay wealthy,

Taylor Schulte, CFP®

Taylor Schulte

I'm the host of the Stay Wealthy Retirement Show and founder of Define Financial, an award-winning retirement and tax planning firm. When I’m not helping people lower their tax bill, you can find me traveling with my wife and kids, searching for the next best carne asada burrito, or trying to master Adam Scott’s golf swing.

Read more from Taylor Schulte

Hi Reader, You may have already noticed, but the title of this note is an oxymoron. There is no such thing as knowledge of the future because, quite literally, the future is unknowable. This is as true in business and the markets as it is in life. In today's email: The disconnect between expectations & reality Predicting versus planning Avoiding investing mistakes First, did you catch the most recent podcast episode? 👇 Small Cap Value Investing (Part 1): Is This Popular Strategy Dead? What...

Hi Reader, Throughout our investing lives, we have learned (or assumed) that: Good economic data = markets go up Bad economic data = markets go down This makes intuitive sense, but our recent investing experience has been anything but normal. In his latest memo, Howard Marks shared the following cartoon that captures the confusing world we've lived in for the past couple of years... ...one where it's been incredibly difficult to discern how the markets will respond to various economic data....

Hi Reader, Today, I’m sharing five of my favorite investing & economic charts from the past month. These charts cover topics such as: Market volatility Investing in gold Inflation...and more! Before we dive in, did you catch this week's podcast episode? Retirement, Taxes, and Investment Underperformance In this episode, I provide key takeaways from three of the BEST retirement articles I read this month. One of the articles makes a strong case for why taxes will be HIGHER in the future....